Bay FC Signs Jenna Nighswonger from Arsenal

Bay FC has successfully agreed to a deal for USWNT fullback Jenna Nighswonger, marking her return to the NWSL after a challenging spell in England. The move is valued at approximately $200,000, as confirmed by multiple sources.

The stakes are high as Bay FC welcomes Jenna Nighswonger back to the National Women's Soccer League. The talented fullback, previously with Arsenal, is set to bring her experience and skill to a team that is currently seeking to enhance its performance after a difficult season.

Nighswonger's transition to Bay FC comes after a rocky spell in England, where she struggled to secure a regular place in the starting lineup. After joining Arsenal in January 2025 from Gotham FC for around $100,000, her time with the Gunners saw limited action, participating in just five league matches. Though she was part of the squad that celebrated a UEFA Women's Champions League title, she did not play in the final.

Before her stint in England, Nighswonger was a standout player in the NWSL, where she made a significant impact as a rookie. Selected as the No. 4 overall pick in the 2023 NWSL Draft, she helped Gotham FC clinch its first championship, earning the NWSL Rookie of the Year title in the process. Her prowess on the field quickly earned her a spot on the USWNT, where she participated in the 2024 Olympics and contributed to the team’s gold medal success.

Now, with Bay FC positioned 14th in the league standings, Nighswonger’s arrival is crucial. The team has struggled offensively, scoring only 18 goals in 17 games, which is the second-lowest in the league. Head coach Emma Coates, in her first year, is looking to bolster both the defense and attack. Nighswonger will compete for a full-back position, hoping to shore up a defense that, while competitive, needs more support to help turn the tide in their favor.

The acquisition of Nighswonger follows the recent signing of midfielder Claire Hutton and attacking midfielder Kennedy Fuller, indicating Bay FC's commitment to rebuilding and improving their squad. As they aim to climb the table, Nighswonger’s experience and talent could be key in helping Bay FC find its form and ascend in the league standings.

With Nighswonger back in the fold, fans will be eager to see how she integrates into the team and impacts their performances in the coming matches. This move not only marks a fresh start for Nighswonger but also a pivotal moment for Bay FC as they strive for improvement in the NWSL.